View Issue Details

Jump to NotesJump to History
IDProjectCategoryView StatusDate SubmittedLast Update
0000236Main CAcert WebsiteGPG/PGPpublic2006-05-12 22:322013-01-14 08:38
Reportermjansen Assigned ToSourcerer  
PrioritynormalSeveritymajorReproducibilityalways
Status closedResolutionfixed 
Fixed in Version2007 
Summary0000236: I always get "No emails found on your key" when trying to sign a GPG Pubkey
DescriptionI tried to sign my GPG key which at first contains only 1 email address and got "No emails found on your key".

Then I added two additional IDs but still I get the same error.

The Key has a sign from the german PC magazine "C't Magazin" so I tried with a minimal export but even with that I get the same message.

When I import the file in a newly created account mit gnupg I get all 3 emailaddresses in the pubkeyring so the pubkey seems to be correct.

I add my pubkey so you can test it:

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.2.2 (GNU/Linux)
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=FHff
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
TagsNo tags attached.
Reviewed by
Test Instructions

Relationships

related to 0000460 closedSourcerer Please disable GPG signing until we have a production-quality system 

Activities

falkinhan

2006-05-16 09:46

reporter   ~0000228

this problem is repeatable with any key

Jan

2007-03-29 13:06

reporter   ~0000828

Maybe the issue is solved with bug 343 being solved? https://bugs.cacert.org/view.php?id=343
Can someone still confirm this error?

executive_override

2007-03-29 13:29

reporter   ~0000829

The problem still happens for me. Here's my public key:

----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: PGP Key Server 0.9.6
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=4Ylb
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

Jan

2007-05-16 20:18

reporter   ~0000844

Perhaps the key from executive_override is wrong? I couldn't import it into my keyring: "No valid OpenPGP block found". What kind of key is it? Try a clean export, perhaps.
It worked ok with mjansen's key from the original bug report.

Sourcerer

2007-07-30 21:10

administrator   ~0000883

Can anyone who still has the problem please contact Sourcerer on irc.cacert.org #cacert ?

Sourcerer

2007-11-17 14:04

administrator   ~0000951

Please test again now, the problem should be fixed.

Sourcerer

2007-12-19 23:12

administrator   ~0000972

I get a nice table now with correct results, so I guess that the issue is solved now.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2006-05-12 22:32 mjansen New Issue
2006-05-16 09:46 falkinhan Note Added: 0000228
2006-08-14 02:50 duane Status new => needs work
2006-08-14 02:50 duane Assigned To => Sourcerer
2007-03-29 13:06 Jan Note Added: 0000828
2007-03-29 13:29 executive_override Note Added: 0000829
2007-05-16 20:18 Jan Note Added: 0000844
2007-07-30 21:10 Sourcerer Note Added: 0000883
2007-10-24 05:10 evaldo Relationship added related to 0000460
2007-11-17 14:04 Sourcerer Note Added: 0000951
2007-12-19 23:12 Sourcerer Status needs work => closed
2007-12-19 23:12 Sourcerer Note Added: 0000972
2007-12-19 23:12 Sourcerer Resolution open => fixed
2007-12-19 23:12 Sourcerer Fixed in Version => production
2013-01-14 08:38 Werner Dworak Fixed in Version => 2007